Teacher Pay Scale Across Canada

Type: 
Stories
Keywords: 
teacher pay scale, salary, salary grid, salary schedule, canada comparison

I couldn't believe it. I was in shock when I actually looked it up. This last year, I was making $30,000 less in Quebec than if I was working as a teacher in Alberta. I used to live in Alberta, and therefore I can't believe that I am worth so much less, just by living a few provinces down; and this doesn't even include the huge taxes that are taken off here in Quebec as opposed to Alberta.

Previously, I wrote a post about salaries in Canada and how they compare to test scores. Higher Teacher Salary = Better Education. In that post I was stunned at how correlated those two values were. But it seemed like the pay scale were somewhat comparable (plus or minus a 5 thousand dollars). But I was comparing statistics from 2001. Not now! Just a few years later and now there's a HUGE difference in the salaries.

Since it was not so easy for me to look up the most recent salary grids for all the provinces (a lot of clever internet searching, including emailing some schools for first hand information), I thought I would post all the provinces' teaching salary scales here (as a comparison), for future reference, for myself and anybody else that wants to know.

Just a few guidlines:

In most provinces, the salary is not the same in all cities / districts, but within 10% of each other. I'll therefore take a sample of a city I wouldn't mind living in (usually smaller cities can't attract as many teachers, so they pay more than the big cities). Also, the salaries usually depend on the amount of years of university/college, and years of teaching experience. I will use my university years (6 years - 4 yrs undergrad, 2 yrs ed. after-degree) and teaching experience (8 years) as an example. If you want to check for yourself, I give links to the actual sites from which I got the information, thus you can check the salary for you specifically.

Enjoy:

Province Salary Year Link
British Columbia (Vancouver Island) $72,242 2008 Vancouver Island North Payscale
Alberta (Calgary) $74,299 2007 Collective agreement - ATA
Saskatchewan $67,293 2007 Collective Agreement - STF
Manitoba (Winnipeg) $74,317 2008 Collective Bargaining - MTS
Ontario (Toronto) $75,688 2007 Collective Agreement - OSSTF
Quebec $46,341 2007 Collective Agreement - QPAT
New Brunswick $57,126 2008 None - negotiations under way.
Nova Scotia (Halifax) $67,277 2007 Collective Agreement - NSTU
P.E.I. $60,296 2008 PEITF Handbook
Newfoundland $61,899 2007 Collective Agreement -NLTA

I's not only Alberta! Most provinces are on par with Alberta. It's Quebec - as if it was in Medieval times. What is up with that? This can't last long. If in Ontario and New Brunswick (the two neighbouring provinces) are $10,000 to $30,000 higher than here in Quebec, there is no way Quebec will not have to catch up with the salary - It's risking a major shortage of teachers in the next few years. Next year, I'm looking for a job in Ontario (I'm only a half hour away... I might as well move that half hour away, to save on taxes also). I cannot believe Quebec... where are these enormous taxes going to? - not the teachers, that's for sure!

Also see: Are Teachers Worth the Money?

If you enjoyed this article, please fill in the quick and anonymous Salary Survey, so I can compile a set of real teacher salary data and post the results here at a later time. Thanks in advance.

Laughable...

I've read through a lot of this, and while both sides of the argument have their merits, I must say there are some on here who have obviously learned little from their teachers, or from anyone else for that matter.

First off, Punch - that you have slacker teachers as friends should not be fuel for you to paint all teachers with the same brush. I grew up with a mother who spent more time during the days and the breaks attending to work-related matters than she did with the family. Her own brother, a chartered accountant and DG of a hospital, doesn't invest the same hours into his work. I'm in my 11th year of teaching, and while I'm not as invested in it as my mother was, I still easily log 10 hours on work days and at least another 4 or 5 during the weekends, and I don't get to claim any over-time for them.

Bay Street - you sound like a student who was freshly tossed out of class, and have an axe to grind - your numbers are so far off the mark it's laughable. If you want to make your argument even slightly compelling, at least use some facts that have a bearing in reality. I'd love to have a job that only demanded 6 months of service. As for getting a real degree - I have three of them, thank you. It is apparent from your general attitude that you hold teachers in a pretty low esteme - why don't you step up to the plate and give it a swing - if you lasted a week in one of my 38 student groups I'd be amazed.

With regards to these breaks teachers get - well, yeah, there is some expectation of work being done, but please keep in mind, teachers aren't paid for the summer break, we pay for it. Anyone on here who thinks a provincial government is benevolent enough to simply give a teacher 2 months off paid is sadly mistaken - a teacher's salary is based on 10 months of work, but the sum is divided into 12 months so they have income over the summer break. This was done, for the most part, to decrease the number of teachers applying for EI benefits during the summer...ironically, teachers, even tenured teachers, still have to pay EI deductions from their salaries...

At some point, however, people need to either shit or get off the pot. Anyone who goes into this profession thinking they're going to retire wealthy is delusional - it is a low paying profession - particularly considering the amount of time, energy and money invested in the required training. That Quebec has a lower salary than other provinces should likewise come as no surprise - this province is living under the mercantile shadow established here 5 centuries ago, and the poverty has only been increased by political stupidity, corruption, and futile attempts to confirm it is "different". There are benefits - my wife and I are both teachers. We trade off the higher salaries for having breaks at the same time as our children.

Comparing Quebec to other provinces is as pointless in a way as comparing teaching to other professions. The sad fact of the matter is Quebec teachers are bent over the barrel for one very simple reason - the rest of Canada cannot provide work for thousands of francophone teachers, and the Quebec government knows it.

Comparing cost of living is tough - I worked in Northern Alberta, where the cost of living was reasonable. A friend working in Edmonton paid much more in rent than IK was paying for a house, so the col was not comparable within the province, let alone compared to others. If I were to crunch the numbers, I took home more in Alberta in my second year of teaching after bills than I take home now, in Quebec, in my 11th - I don't care how you slice it, or what your opinion of teachers is - that is messed up.

"I still easily log 10 hours

"I still easily log 10 hours on work days and at least another 4 or 5 during the weekends, and I don't get to claim any over-time for them."

Makes you sound almost like a fellow engineering student!

thats why i work 6 hours a

thats why i work 6 hours a day with an hour lunch.....gross is about 375 dollars so you do the math. Bell goes and so am i, nurses, bus drivers, even cops dont work for free.

"teachers aren't paid for

"teachers aren't paid for the summer break, we pay for it"
"it is a low paying profession"

What a serious disconnect with reality! Good God, the Toronto elementary teacher contract will be paying $94,000 by 2012. With benefits, security, time off and pension what other professions are better? Dentists, doctors, lawyers perhaps...certainly not mine (software developer). Mind you, I was listening to a doctor complain the other day about how her profession was underpaid....

In Ontario that is in fact

In Ontario that is in fact the highest salary a teacher can get (after 10 years of experience in group 4 - many years of post grad. education). This is a really nice salary, and I would be very happy making this amount - no complaints.

But my point is that I am living only a few hundred km East (in Quebec): and I make half of this salary, after 10 year of experience...

Well put... I agree on all

Well put... I agree on all accounts!

I am not a teacher, but my

I am not a teacher, but my mom was one for about 25 years. She worked in the Regent Park area of Toronto. Looking back at when I went to high school, my school wasn't (at the time) semestered. We wrote our exams in December. When we got back after the Christmas break, our exams were returned. This means that those teachers spent part of their Christmas break marking exams. Also, its not like the 6-6.5 hours in the classroom is all the work the teacher does.

I'm 32 years old and making

I'm 32 years old and making $102,000 as of this year, teaching near ottawa. :)

Can you please let me know

Can you please let me know where you're teaching, how many years of education you have? Thanks.

That's awesome! Is it a

That's awesome!

Is it a private school? How can I get a job at your school?

Besides being the lowest, do

Besides being the lowest, do not forget that workers in Quebec pay a much higher provincial tax rate. i worked in Montreal for 3 months when I was in the military and found that during that time, I paid 150% of the federal tax rate to quebec.

$1000 to Ottawa, $1500 to Quebec
Most other provices are a portion of that.
BC about 45 - 50 %, NB and NF 60-68% federal. % are just approximates based on numbers around 2002/3. However, I do understand that cost of living is cheaper in Qu.

Just a thought.

Your article

Thanks for this article and the research that went behind it. I too am shocked. I'm starting my first year as a university undergrad with the hopes of becoming a teacher in Quebec. I currently live in Montreal, and although I would consider moving, I have to admit I am very comfortable here. Well, when I saw the differences in salaries, my eyes just about popped out of my head: not only was I surprised, but somewhat pissed off. Why are teachers so undervalued here? Why would anyone want to be a teacher here when the salaries in other provinces are so much higher? Are there some kind of hidden benefits that aren't immediately evident?. I expected salaries to be lower, but the margins are ridiculous. Well thanks for tip off, I'll keep this in consideration when considering my future options.

Canada vs US vs Portugal (Europe)

Hi there.
I have been looking up for info about how to become a QC teacher, since that has been on my mind ever since I lived in Montreal for a short amount of time back in 2003. I'm an ESl and EFl and Modern Languages Teacher, who hold a BEd from an european teacher's college and a Masters in TESOL from a well-known american university. I taught in Ireland, England, in the States until I went back to my home country Portugal. I have to say that this was a really stupid move. Although the move was for family reasons, I should have had stayed put. I taught in the States while I was taking my Masters in TESOL at the University's language Centre and got some ESL-related jobs at the same time. After my MA I got certified for Maryland and passed all tests and interviews and became a public school teacher in MD. At the same time I taught an ESL course for pre-beginners at a local community college every Saturday morning. As a first year teacher (2002) I was making 41k a year plus getting comfortable money from the comm. college. When all this happens like this, you end thinking that it might be a little like this everywhere. I know, too young, too dumb. When I decided to go back to my home country I thought that three years away wouldn't make a difference and that, with my qualifications and experience I would get a teaching job at a state school, where pay is higher. Big mistake. In Portugal they don't care how good you are, how well qualified you are or what kind of experience you've got. You're just a number in a lottery contest and that's how you get a placement in a public school. And since they hold teachers for over 35 years at their jobs, it's too hard to get in and when you finally get a yearly contract, this doesn mean you'll get one the following year and you'll be living out of 15k after taxes for as well as 15 years if you're lucky. You're never guaranteed a place within the Ministry. They save thousands of euros this way. And before you say life is cheap here, hold on your horses. I have the excat same expenses now (2010) than I had in the States back in 2002. Yes food out is extremely good and cheap but the rest is outrageous and with a mere 1100 per month you don't go far.
This is why I can't accept that, after teaching for 11 years and being more qualified than my own Minister of Education (although she's a well-known writer here) and way more qualified than my own PM I still don't make ends meat and nobody appreciated you here, since you're may not even be in the same school year after year and you never know until a day before September contracts begin if you're going to have a job that year.
Sad, but true. Salaries are low everyhwere. Extremely underpaid in most countries for what teachers work. Yes, if we do feel underappreciated we do have the right to complain.
Cheers and hope to meet some of you in Montreal one day.

Portuguese Education

While I agree that there are several problems with Portuguese education, they are not all that different from those in other parts of the world. I find your evaluation of Portugal quite condemning for those who may not know it that well. I am currently teaching in Montreal and our max. salary is around $70,000. I did my student-teaching in Ottawa and my cooperating teacher was already earning $78,000 in her twelfth year of teaching. That's supposedly the same country; unfortunately education falls under provincial jurisdiction.

We also have a union so after your two years of probation, you're basically also guaranteed your job for 35 years unless you do something really awful. Not all that different from what happens in Portugal. Also, we have teachers here who spend 5-10 years on replacement contracts without becoming tenured because teachers go on leave for years at a time and the school boards/unions aren't as vigilant as they should be in forcing these teachers to resign or return to the workforce. In the French school boards, it's even more difficult to obtain tenure.

I do agree that you may be more intelligent than the Minister of Education and the PM combined, but when one makes these claims, perhaps one should check their grammar and spelling, especially if that's what you claim to be specialized in. I don't mean to be rude but when someone is so cocky and claims to be so wonderful and God's gift to education with so much experience and so many qualifications (at unnamed well-known American universities), then one should put their money where their mouth is. If you are supposed to be teaching languages and your syntax/spelling is off, then maybe it's not the system, maybe it's you. I ignored most of it, but couldn't help reacting when I saw "making ends meat". I'm sorry, but it's just very difficult for me to take someone seriously when I see these kinds of mistakes, especially when it's your field.

Bachelor in Physical and Health Education

Hi Everyone,

My sister would like to complete a bachelors degree in Physical and Health Education and follow it up with a masters. Her goal is to work as a CEGEP level teacher here in Montreal. I found this site very useful as we were researching on how much money she could potentially make. If anyone could help me out I would appreciate it. What is the starting off salary and where would she potentially cap off?

Thanks,

Anything will be helpful :)

I think that public CEGEP

I think that public CEGEP teachers make the same amount of money as regular teachers (same scale), but since they have a masters they make a step up. But I don't know for sure.

The collective agreement is about to be renegotiated (March 31, 2010 is when the previous agreement expires). Your sister will have new salaries to look forward to.

I was just as shocked!

As you can imagine I was also shocked. The margins are just ridiculous!

ME too

i was aswell, homie.

To become teacher in Toronto

Since the most recent post is current, I am hoping someone could answer my question.

I am very confused who could be teacher in Toronto. Do I have to have a degree in education? What if I already have a degree in computer engineering, B.A. Sc. from UT. Can I start before I finish my education degree, is there program allow me to work in the classrooms while I am studying for my necessary qualification?

Will my work exp count? I have about 15 yrs exp. in programming and worked in wall street for a decade. I have good skill in math, finance and computer. And hope to teach similar subjects in high school, I believe I can manage physic and chemistry too.

What is the base salary for a teacher with a education degree? or with just a non related degree?

To be a teacher in Toronto

To be a teacher in Toronto you need to have a bachelor of education (B.Ed) from a school that offers a teacher education program recognized by the Ontario Ministry of Education. Before you complete your B.Ed you generally need to already have a 4 year degree. It really depends on whether you want to teach at the elementary, middle school or high school level. To teach at the intermediate level (4-10), you need to have one 'teachable' subject as determined by classes taken in your undergraduate degree. For the senior level (7-12), you need to have two teachables. For elementary you do not need to have a teachable, however some schools require that you have taken classes that cover a wide range of subjects. It is very competitive to get in and therefore you also generally need to have experience working with kids, volunteering etc. You are not able to work in a classroom in Ontario without your B.Ed. Good luck getting a job in Toronto, there are virtually no positions available. Also, salary depends on education and how many years you have been with the Board. Hope this helps!

I think the level of emotion

I think the level of emotion indicates sensitive toes on all sides. Certainly it does not show that any of the participants are really comfortable with their positions. That is often the case when you compare money and contribution.

However, I don't care about any of the baggage that arrived with the comments. The only problem I have is with the numbers. They are not accurately presented. You are not using "real" numbers (in the statistical sense).

You need to include cost of living, local inflationary pressures, other jobs in the area (comparable) and job requirements. There are also pensions and other benefits to include in your salary comparisons. There are many benefits in Qc that are not included in the salaries. This is BECAUSE of the high taxes. If you are a teacher in Qc you have access to certain 'perks' that teachers in other provinces do not, these are not paid as salary because if they were your taxes would come into play. Therefore when the union negotiates, they ask for things that are not directly included in salary.

Yes, Bay Street has some points. If you include the benefits then the salary is not the same as someone in the private sector. Bay Street will eat you up and spit you out and you have no guarantees. There are often no vacations, bad quality of life, high cost of living and really, unhealthy stress levels. Teaching in Qc offers rights, pensions, additional medical coverage, leaves of absence, paid vacation time (that no one can "guilt" you out of by threatening your job is gone if you take it, the way they routinely do in the private sector)

But it does "feel" when you look at raw numbers like that as though you are being 'put out' by getting less money.

I have worked in the private sector for 20 years. I have no pension and no hopes of having one. I have not had a vacation in the last 7 years. I routinely work week nights, weekends, and holidays for "free". I have no job security, my work is not valued, I have no social context at work and will be "replacable" by younger cheaper workers for the remained of my work life. There is no effort or compensation from my employer to help me keep my skills current and when I take classes so that my worklife continues as long as I need it to: I pay for the time and tuition out of my pocket. (unpaid time off work) I have not had a raise in 7 years and I cannot ask for more money because cheaper, younger workers would take my current job in a heart beat.

I would love to get into teaching, and the "low" salary in Qc does not bother me. It would just be nice to have a job where I did something with a "value" to society and a possible pension/sick leave when something happens to me.

If you want "cash" to show you that you are valued, by all means go back to Alberta, Qc is not culturally appropriate for you.

Whose fault is it that you

Whose fault is it that you have an under par job.

R you serious? While I

R you serious? While I don't like it when other teachers whine about their salaries, in this instance the difference is very unfair. If you're looking for pity don't insult people with legitimate concerns, otherwise no one will be concerned with you.

It's too bad that

It's too bad that "anonymous" is personally stuck in a low-paying job, but that isn't really a relevant reason why teachers should be paid so much less in Quebec than in other parts of the country.

As for telling teachers who feel under-appreciated to go back to Alberta, the issues facing Quebec teachers affect all teachers in the province, even those who grew up here and are lucky enough to be "culturally appropriate".

However, there are a few reasons why I can understand that teaching salaries (including the higher taxes) are lower here in Quebec: the public services offered are in fact quite a bit more extensive than in Alberta. Bogusia named daycare, but in reality, there is much more. Just off the top of my head: Montreal has a much more advanced public transit system than either Edmonton or Calgary; Quebec subsidises post-secondary education to much greater extent than Alberta; Quebec has a publicly funded prescription drug plan that Alberta does not.

In addition, Alberta is the recipient of billions of dollars yearly in oil royalties. However, a counter-point to this is that Quebec and Ontario benefited for decades from being the industrial centre of the country and reaped the corresponding financial rewards in the form of corporate taxes and federal spending.

To me, all of this means that the issue is much more complicated than simply after-tax salaries or who is "culturally appropriate" to live in Quebec. In the end, I still think that Quebec teachers are underpaid relative to their counterparts in the rest of the country.

Quebec's taxes don't pay for that much...

You are right - the salary doesn't take into account all the costs of living, although in Canada, apart from the housing market, the cost of food and other goods is pretty comparable. This is why it is hard to compare different countries, but within Canada I think it is reasonable to compare just pure salaries.

However there's a few points which I would like to point to from your comment. I am working in a private school and there is no pension provided (in Quebec). The public sector and other private schools do give pensions, but I'm just showing you that if you decide to get into teaching, it might be hard to get a job with a pension.

On top of that, everybody thinks that Quebec has really great services for the taxes that we pay here. Well it's true that child care is great (we pay $7/day here), but I think that's it. I can't think of another absolutely beneficial (in terms of money saving) service that we have here compared to Alberta (the other side of the spectrum in terms of taxes). In fact because of the higher taxes - on our home, on our salaries, on the gas, on everything you buy etc, - I feel like I pay way more here for the cost of living.

I once did a comparison of how much I would make here in Montreal vs. Calgary, assuming I was working full time here, full time there, having three children in daycare here vs. there (in Calgary daycare is more like $30 - $40 / day), owing a house here compared to there, etc., and it turned out that I still would be ahead of the game in Calgary.

I love Quebec, don't get me wrong, but I really don't know where all the taxes are going to? Probably to pay off the debt / deficit - but not to the services everybody says we have.

Teachers only work half a year...

No more whining about your salaries. Teachers only work 6 months a year, so if you are making $75k for 6 months, your annual salary (if you actually worked a full year like the rest of us) would be $150k per year.

Add that to the fact you are teaching ABCs and counting to 10, and you are well-paid for what you do!

If you want to kill it, get an MBA, work 100 hours a week - ALL YEAR. Then you will have a bit more mad money.

Moral of the story - work a full year, get a real degree, or stop whining. You get 6 months off a year, and teach from lesson plans and books as it is.

I welcome your whiny comments.

Bay Street Boy

Re: BS Bay Steet Boy ...this is not a whinge

On the off-chance that this thread has not yet died, I thought I would add an international perspective. It's only the story of a single person - me - I am a teacher in Australia. I am who I am because I had an education dotted with extraordinary teachers (including my own parents and family).

Australia compares similarly in terms of wages and conditions for teachers and other professions, though I think Canada is a tick ahead on the money front for teachers in most areas. In fact the way I came across this blog was in searching for info because I am coming across on a teaching exchange for 12 months and my husband will need to find a job - teaching. The attitude to teachers is strikingly similar - though we have seen this tide slowly turning in the last few years. We can only hope it continues to turn until we see the professional valued and respected as it should be.

I have a Bachelor of Mechanical Engineering and Computing (double degree) and a Bachelor of Technology in Industrial Design. I also have an MBA, earned in my first 5 years working as a design engineer. I worked for almost 10 years in private industry, for two different internationally renowned companies and would probably be considered a "high flyer". I worked hard, I didn't waste company time, I was astute, I invested myself in the company's business wholly and I played the game. For this I was paid well.

However, I decided to opt out and get a teaching qualification. Ultimately, making profit was not meaningful for me, writing reports, giving presentations and playing the politically charged corporate game was empty and quite simply - was not making a positive difference to this world in any way. What a waste of my energies I figured. Success is what you define it as for yourself I suppose. Many saw me as a success but I didn't feel it for myself.

I knew what I was going to be in for as a teacher. My parents are teachers. My in laws are teachers. I was NEVER EVER going to be one...I knew how hard they worked and how undervalued they typically were! When I eventually made my decision it obviously wasn't for the lucrative pay and conditions - it was for ulturistic reasons. It is a decision I will never regret.

I took a year without pay to get my qualification to teach (a graduate diploma K-12). I have now been a teacher for 5 years. I have a passion for teaching far beyond what I ever felt as an Engineer or Designer. For me, and I imagine most teachers, this is an amazing and diverse profession that is challenging and rewarding. It is exhausting and exhilerating. It is heartbreaking and heartwarming. It is a real rollercoaster ride. But one thing is for sure - a vast majority of teachers are in the job for the RIGHT reasons. They want to make a positive difference. They care. They are clever. They are the sort of people you want to trust the education of the next generation to.

I know I make a difference in the lives of children. I know I am doing the very best I can to provide the very best for each and every student. I know I am not perfect and that I still have a lot to learn - but don't we all, no matter our profession? Teachers grow along with their students. This job is such a priviledge.

I won't whinge about the wages... do others really whinge - or do they merely DEFEND this noble profession? Compare with other professions, looking for equity? When attacked and denigrated it is only natural to defend one's livlihood - one's passion. People should be wary of mistaking this for whinging. We do hear some whinging about teachers whinging for sure.

Importantly, people should be wary of mistaking the statement of facts (anecdotal or statistical) as whinging.

If people are stating that it is "not fair" then perhaps people could be sitting up and listening? They would hear the cry of people who feel undervalued. Who continue to do a great job but who perhaps crave the recognition of doing something incredibly difficult and doing it well. It is only human nature to want some basic recogition for a job well done. Instead, they are often served critiscm instead.

Is it so hard to be thankful? If you are reading this then chances are you had some great teachers in your life to guide you. If you have success in your life, if you learned to be a good person, gained skills, were challenged to think and problem solve then perhaps they had some influence in that? Please stop throwing sand in their faces. Thank them. Value them.

The simple truth is I now work much harder for much less as a teacher. I am in a position to directly compare corporate effort and wages to that of teaching. Walk a mile in my shoes...as many teachers have invited. I have walked many miles and I can unequivically state that teachers do get a tough deal in many places. That said, I wouldn't change it for anything.

Luckily I am motivated by more than money and status - as most teachers are, thank goodness. Perhaps that is actually a good pre-requiste to have when you consider the fact that we (teachers) transfer culture...

It is also true that some teachers work harder than others, but it's obvious that most work much harder than the general wider society expect, though there are a growing number of people who DO understand what teachers actually do with their time and energy.

For me it's 10 months of work in school (that's 4 weeks off in total, split between 4 holiday periods). Minimum of an 8 hour day for me (always there by 8 at the latest, leaving after 5, working through lunch 4 out of 5 days). For those with any responsibility position there are extra meetings such as school council, education committe, leadership etc. These often don't finish till 8:30 or 9 pm. Those are loooong days to be sure! Extra-curricula activities (weekend sports teams, competitions, camps, excursions) that go well beyond the typical school day. Luckily they all only happen every other week. I am up at 6:30am and I am rarely in bed before 11:30 (we don't do any work until the kids are in bed). Not a whinge mind you, just how it is (fact).

Courses or conferences that we (must) go on - we usually pay for the travel, often do the travel in our own time and don't get accomodation paid for either. No company car. No expense account. No plush hotels. The cost of the conference is often the only thing covered, if approved. Can you imagine paying for your own hotels, travel etc in other professions? I know I never had to as an Engineer! I have now applied to do a teaching exchange in Canada for 12 months to broaden my experience as an educator, to add some international perspective. For this we will pay all travel and relocation costs for our family of 4 (around $7000 plus the cost of a new car once we arrive). We will cop the difference in exchange rates between our currencies (approx. 10% loss for us). I will not earn a cent more than I currently do. I will work just as hard as I currently do. The person replacing me here will do the same...and we do it because we think it makes a difference to how effective we will be as teachers. Not a whinge, just how it is.

I always wondered why teachers didn't get "danger money" for school camps. Large groups of students (teens 8o) for whom you are responsible for 24 hours a day for the extent of the camp - usually 3 - 5 days, sometimes more (I recently did one trip of 2 weeks with a group of 14-17 year olds, 1 week of school time, 1 week of our holiday time). With no extra pay or time off in-lieu. That's an extra 280 hours by conservative standards, over and above. It's a wonder school camps still run really. The goodness in the hearts of teachers goes a long, long way. They do it for the kids. Not a whinge, just some perspective.

Oh, and others have obviously mentioned the correction, planning and preparation (which is actually what makes a fantastic teacher so fantastic) which is a minimum of 2 hours every night (except when I have those late meetings, those nights I am brain dead by the time I get home). Sometimes we do use textbooks (and some teachers more than others) but most good teachers use it nly as one of a plethora of resources (like computers, interactive whiteboards, manipulatives etc). Good teachers keep learning, keep challemging themselves to do better, to find a different way to teach something, to reach each and every student. A bit of work on weekends as well, not every weekend for me as I try and spend most of it with my young kids. Then there is the good, comprehensive and personal reports that take approximately 1.5 hour per student to write (we recently did a study of this at our school for planning purposes). Most teachers have a few students...some up to 100.

I went back to the bottom of the payscale initially. Even now I don't earn what I did when I was part time (3 days when returning to work after having a child). My credentials and skills as a manager have helped me a secure senior/leading teacher position (rare for a graduate) but this still has me at much less than half what I previously earned. I manage the Middle Years (5-9) curriculum and transition and I am the Year 7 co-ordinator. I also teach a Year 12 Physics class, a Year 12 Maths class, a Year 9 maths class and a Year 7 integrated learning class. I run our extensive Snowsports program and lead/mentor the Student Forum (and the Student Forum Teacher Leader). I am responsible for the Performance and Development of a group of 5 staff (all Expert teachers (15+ years experience)- interesting as I am only a graduate LOL). I write, implement and monitor individual learning plans for 26 students. I coach other teachers. I have implmented several programs in my own school (Restorative Practice, Gifted and Talented program etc). I work around 60 hours a week and one advantage is certainly that it allows me the flexibility to be with my children more than a corporate 60 hour week (and for that I suppose I would pay a premium). I am not ashamed to say I currently do all this for under $60k. This is not a whinge, just reality. I don't regret it for a second.

Teaching is not for everyone obviously. I doubt many would argue that it is a vital profession, that the education of the next generation isn't one of the most important jobs in any country. We educate the future's child. We affect the future of individuals and society as a whole. Whether you like it or not we are a vital link in the fabric of civilised society as it is currently structured. If you want to denigrate our profession so be it, we will continue to do the best we can with what we've got. But, imagine the difference *you* could make if you actually valued and supported what we do.

Of course I would happily do this job for what it's worth, equivalent work for equivalent pay...conservative estimates put it at $150-180k in the western world. I would be delighted with performance based pay - I know I would be a top earner because I put in the effort (as do most teachers by the way). Truth is societies simply can't afford to pay us what we are actually worth. So, if you are not going to pay us what we are actually worth then the least you can do is support us, value what we do and give thanks where it is warranted. Forgive us for defending the profession we are passionate about, forgive us for wanting things to be fairer for all. In a predominantly self-centred, capitalist society we are not doing this for money or status. We are just doing the best we can with what we've got because we know that we need to make a difference and we care enough to sacrifice some of ourselves for that. Someone has to look after our future after all.

This is not a whinge, it is just the facts as I know them.

OOhhh bad street boy

Where on earth does a teacher get 6 months off in the year? I would love to know so I can teach there! Teaching is a high stressful profession. You can't count PD days b/c don't you have to attend meetings or take some more training? Its funny how everyone is critical of a teacher but has no problem that any of our deputy ministers make around $264 000 a year for basically doing nothing with an expense account. Parents can't wait to get rid of their own flesh and blood after the summer and cherish the moment their kid goes back to school. Why is this? Its your own child, if you can't handle them how am I suppose to? What about the other 26 children I have to worry about? During that 10 months i will spend more time with that child than the kids parents. Its funny how parents can't stand their kids and give them video games or anything else to shut them up. Why? B/c when it is 5, they are done work and want to relax but a teacher is still working at night and on the weekends. I also have to watch myself b/c I am a role model and I can't just go wild on the weekends. Its funny how a parent will plan for their child's birthday party and then go crazy b/c of the amount of kids running around, the planning involved and the energy spent for a couple of hours. Well that is teaching 5 days a week, 10 months of the year and from 8 to 4 (if you are lucky) every single day. If you wanted to be a teacher, maybe you should have become one instead of getting your MBA and finding you have no purpose in life. You want to know how much I make? I make a difference, how much do you make?

Teacher's Salaries

Teachers only work 6 months a year? That is news to me Bay Street Boy. Obviously where you went to school they did hence you did not get your proper education. The fact is that teachers are in front of the class 10 months a year. Summers and holidays are spent planning and revising for next year. My work day is 8-4 and then with 2 more hours of planning and marking a night.
I love how the public can make a comment regarding teachingt and not know a thing about it. Their only reference point is when they went to school 30 years ago.
Times and students are different and they job and the social make up of our society is diverse and challenging. This is my 23rd year is in the class and the professional is more challenging than ever.

Tired of misconceptions

I don't know where you went to school, but teachers here on the East Coast work 10 months a year, with lesson plans that WE make up ourselves, often with no guides, direction, and in many rural area schools, not even any textbooks. Then, we're expected (and most of us do) devote those precious few "free" hours of our evening and weekend lives to extra-curricular teaching and travelling that we don't get paid for at all. Teaching is not a cushion job, nor is it for the faint of heart. It is a virtually 24/7 thankless job, with bottom-dweller reputations AND pay.

Lastly, if you think we're getting such a great deal, why aren't you a teacher? No one's stopping you.

Bay Street Boy

I worked on Bay St for 9 years, at one of the large financial institutions that are found there. I had 3 weeks of paid vacation, a good salary, and a company bonus paid out twice a year (end of June, end of December) and I worked 70 - 80 hr weeks. I grew tired of pushing paper to justify cutting expenditures, and to contributing to having the corporation earn vast amounts of money that was paid back to the executives, and all the talk of shareholder value - that was mostly talk to cover the decision to make upcoming cuts or even layoffs. I felt that I was not contributing, or making a difference to anyone but to those who were making 6 and 7 digit bonuses.

I went back to school to do my BEd, and was fortunate enough to get a job teaching right out of teacher's college at the TDSB. I have worked for TDSB for 7 years now, I still put in 70 - 80hr weeks (including coaching, marking, etc.) but the difference is I now feel like I am making a difference in my community, my city, and my society. I make about 25 - 30% less than I did while on Bay St. but teaching isn't solely about making money. The two months off are a bonus, and really they are worth not making that extra 25%. Unfortunately, it sounds like Quebec (even though it has a number of social programs) is not paying its teachers a fair wage for the amount of work that they do, or at least in comparison with the rest of Canada.

However, becoming a teacher for the money and vacation time is like becoming a professional athlete for the travel. It is not what should drive you, or keep you happy in your job. The opportunity to contribute, and to learn from others is so much more rewarding. If you wish to retire rich find a job on Bay St., because you won't get there as a teacher.

hmm

I am a new teacher which means I have been teaching for less than 10 years and I have a Master's degree. I work for several different CEGEPs and I don't clear $30,000 a year. I am not sure what planet you are living on, but teachers here in Montreal are struggling. With a Master's degree and a job, I don't know why I should have to struggle so much. Teachers work 8 months out of the year, and as a new teacher I work 8+ hours a day seven days a week when I can get work that is.

I'm pretty late to this

I'm pretty late to this game, but I just discovered this page.

I find it funny that the critics here are using BS numbers to justify their criticism. On what planet do teachers only work 6 mos a year and make 70k? Nowhere. Kids are only out of school for two months, finishing at the end of June, and returning at the end of August/beginning of Sept, depending on the province. They may get an additional two weeks at Christmas, but are usually back at work before the students.

I know for a fact that teachers don't get the full two months off - they, as others have stated, have to organize their materials, clean the classroom, sit in meetings with administration about where to place their students in the coming year, do professional development, and then start preparing for the incoming class. So basically they probably get maybe one month off over the Summer, which is about on par with equal-paying jobs in the private sector).

In addition, if they're doing their jobs properly, they're supposed to be attending conferences, reading, upgrading their qualifications and all those other things that professionals are supposed to do to remain current.

Nevermind the extracurriculars, chaperoning, monitoring and tutoring that happens during the year.

No one can guarantee that they're actually doing what they're supposed to be, but they're paid with the assumption that they are.

I think that the hours they do, with all that included, should be pretty close to a full time job.

Also keep in mind that this chart was for a teacher with 6 years of education, plus experience. The average teacher makes 30k - 45k to start, depending on their education. Most Master's level jobs start at 60k in the public sector. There are entry level positions with a lot of private companies that require NO education that pay 30k-40k to start. The idea that someone should accept making 45k with an MEd and 8 years of experience is crazy.

Like any job, increased responsibility comes with increased pay. A teacher has to babysit large classes of increasingly badly behaved kids, deal with increasing behavioural issues, developmental delays, and generally do a lot of extra work to cover where the parents are failing.

The job also comes with a great deal of social responsibility to ensure that kids are actually learning and developing normally. 30k-45k to do that is nothing. they should be paid more.

General Practitioners do about the same work and get paid about 5 times as much to do it (no nonsense about life saving, please, they deal with the same 10 scenarios all day every day and none of it involves saving lives).

All that is moot though, the question addressed here is not how much is being paid, but why there's such a substantial difference between Quebec and every other province. The answer is easy - Quebec's economic problems lead to agreements with unions to slow wage increases in the 90s.

The situation for teachers in QC is far from ideal, but QCs economic situation for many years was far from ideal. It should be noted that the provincial government has been taking steps recently to improve wages and benefits for civil servents, which includes teachers.

I know many teachers and am

I know many teachers and am married to one, she is a great teacher but get real on the hours. I work outside the education field and I put in more overtime 12 months a year (and don't get pd for it). She admits she is paid fairly, she does put in overtime but is realistic that many jobs have overtime required that isn't paid for. As for prep over summer, if a teacher is half decent at their jobs most of that time IS time off! They don't have to recreate the wheel every summer!

As for overall time off compared to professions outside teaching, they do get a lot more, I just got 4 weeks vacation - so don't even go there!!

Teachers vs MBAs

What do MBAs do for 100 hrs per week? They make pie charts and powerpoints and reports. I know because I am an MBA. What is the responsibility level of your average MBA? Not much: Usually it's making sure the numbers from page two add up to the number on page one.

Teachers have heavy responsibility, and we should pay for that responsibility. They are, or should, be responsible for the outcome of the children of society. By paying them so little we also say that we expect little from them. And when we expect little, we get little.

We have whiny teachers because they are rendered powerless by the administrators. All they can do is whine. They are given a herd of undisciplined kids and told, without many resources, to cram a curriculum into their brains so they can pass some test. They don't have much say in what they can teach, nor how they can teach it. Their wages are set by someone far away and merit is unrewarded.

Teachers should be worth more than a mere MBA chart-maker, and they should be held accountable for results. If all they do is read the textbook and babysit then they are paid what they are worth now; but then where is our future going?

Well put!

Well put!

teacher's salaries

i must admit that i have to agree with the bay street boy. most, not all, of the teachers that i know whine about how tough a job they have. and i would agree that over time it has gotten tougher due to the polical correctness of society. challenges have increased with regards to discipline. and maybe the "fun" has decreased over time. however, those teacher friends of mine that are being truly honest, and there are a few, will readily concede that life is pretty good. not many jobs exist where after 10 years you can be making $60-80,000 for an incomplete years worth of work. indeed, you can spend your summers upgrading so that you can make even more money. all on the public's dime. the pension is gold-plated and the benefits are reasonable. the curriculum is spelled out; the daily planners are given to you; you don't even need to know your subject -- the notes are given to you. the marking scheme is predetermined; the report card comments are from canned programs. cut 'n' paste. and you have to set up and clean your own room before and after the school term? c'est domage. a downturn in the economy? ..... do you have any conception of what that means and how it affects the average joe?? no you don't because even if you suck as a teacher we can't get rid of you. you continue to collect your pay and have your extravagant hollidays. so, don't be complaining because no-one, other than your fellow narcissists, feels sorry for you. -- JOE

Wow I came upon this page

Wow I came upon this page upon speaking with a friend that is married to an elementary school teacher and he laughingly informed me that she "earns" just shy of $90000 a year. Even he conceded that was an outrageous sum for what teachers actually do. While I sympathize with teachers for what they have to put up with daily from students, parents and administrators this is no different from what any person puts up with at a normal job and they are no where near to compensation that teachers are paid. My point in even posting here is the average Joe has little sympathy for poor, unappreciated teachers that work 6 hours a day for 9 months a year and are paid better than 90% of the population. Get a grip, stop whining and do your fucking job and you wouldn't see as many people with negative attitudes toward your profession.

...married to a teacher and

...married to a teacher and he talks like that...won't be married for long....

hard to believe

Hey JohnnyPunchClock. I cannot believe that your friend's wife makes $90,000. A lot of teaching pay scales have a ceiling of less than that (so after working 25 year they cannot make more than the ceiling). Where does she work (which province / country)? I would love to move there. I think if teachers did make that kind of money, then we would have a the best country of all... The people going into teaching would be of a high caliber and our young generation would benefit!

Now I would like to address the issue of working 6h a day for 9months. I think I will write a post on this, because it comes up a lot. What is the actual working day of a teacher? It's really not just the teaching. More about that later...

13 years ago (1997) I was

13 years ago (1997) I was dating a newly hired 24 year old elementary school teacher. On her second year on the job she was making 45000 a year. Teaching summer school would net her another 5K. Very well paid salary indeed. She never ever complained about her job or her pay.

But like many public service jobs in our country, many of them quickly lose grasp of reality.

I have no problem with school teachers getting the salary they do when compared to the monkeys at OPG Nuclear. Average education is 2 year college and average salary is just under 90K a year. With overtime some of them are making 130-150K, we are talking general labour not nuclear scientists.

@hard to believe, Believe

@hard to believe,

Believe it. Oh and before you try and make laughable assertions about teachers burning the midnight oil after school marking. preparing lesson plans and doing extra-curriculor I should mention that I personally know probably 20 teachers in Ontario and my own mother was a teacher (recently retired). I know not one teacher that spends any significant time doing prep work after school - it's a fallacy. Even if teachers spent 2 hours extra every single day they would still only be working 8 hours which is the least most people work. STOP WHINING

awww...you just don't get it...

I have spent many a night going to bed while my mother was up marking papers til 2 in the morning. Many times during a late night dance practice, she was marking papers and nodding off from being so tired!! Students and their parents request to have her as a teacher. She should be paid as much as possible for guiding young minds and giving them the tools to succeed in University!!
My father (an MBA) spent his nights watching TV and was paid a bit more than my mother.......all this info on teachers not doing prep work and working overtime is coming from someone who is VERY uninformed. Perhaps you mother was not as dedicated. . .or perhaps she didn't teach English. . .which (trust me) creates stacks of papers to mark! There are also two ways of marking an essay . . .the easy way, and the dedicated "right" way. Teachers who care more for their spare time make these VERY dedicated teachers look bad to people (like you) who have no vision and are misguided by this. You are really generalizing here based on only YOUR personal observations!!!

If you had my mother for a teacher, you may have turned out to be much more of a deep thinker!

WOW! I can not believe that

WOW! I can not believe that there are still ignorant people such as yourself Bay Street Boy. I challenge you to spend a day in the classroom and then get back to me. We only work 6 months? It's actually more like 10 months. Do you think that classrooms magically clean themselves at the end of June? NO! That takes time. And who do you think sets them up and plans for the entire year all of August? That's right, teachers do. PS: teachers don't make that much until they work about 8-10 years. most start at $30,000 less. If you think all we do is teach kids to say their ABC's and count their 123's then you are certainly living in your own imaginary world. You do realize that we need to follow something called the CURRICULUM right? Did you learn just your ABC's and 123's in school... it seems like it. And lesson plans? Yeah, we do teach from lesson plans, that WE WRITE OURSELVES! They don't just write themselves, they take alot of time and planning. Amazing teachers spend hours planning lessons to engage students and keep them interested in their learning. They also write up something called report cards. I'd like to see you write one. We may get more like ONE month off a year, but it is well deserved. Going into teaching we also only get holidays at the peak times, we can just take vacation whenever we want, Something that we sacrifice when we sign up. As for you, do your research about the timeand effort it takes to be a teacher and then come talk to me. I would like to meet your teachers, because if that's all you think they did in your education then they were obviously not doing your job. You probably were just sitting in the back, not paying attention.

Dear Bay Street Boy, I am a

Dear Bay Street Boy,

I am a young man who is presently working on his undergraduate degree and his B.Ed. in Nova Scotia.

Clearly, sir, you have no idea what you're talking about. Have you ever taken a teaching program yourself? Have you ever accompanied a teacher inside and outside the classroom to see how much work is actually involved in the profession?

As far as making "$75k for 6 months" as you say, there are few teachers who make such a salary. In fact, $65 000 per year is more realistic. Do the research.

You say that we teach ABCs and count to ten. If that's all you learned in school or if all you think that is being taught, you have a very poor vision of education. Education is about molding and developping the minds of children and adolescents, the minds that will lead us in the future. Are you aware that teachers offer such courses as biology, physics, calculus, accounting, French language, law?

You then say that we should get a real degree. What does that even mean? Are you proposing that we all run out and get our MBAs like you?

You also say that we teach from lesson plans and books. I wasn't aware of this and neither are my university professors. Imagine our surprise because all these years, we have been preparing our own lesson plans each night, one different lesson plan for each class that we teach (which can be up to five classes, by the way). You must therefore provide me with more details as to where I can obtain these magnificent resources!

Sir, the purpose of my comment is not to complain about teachers' salaries. As a matter of fact, I'd like to tell you that I agree with you, "[teachers] are well paid for what [they] do". Instead, I want to show you (and whomever else decides to read this discussion) that your comment is not credible in any way. As you have a MBA, you should understand the importance of checking your facts and you have not done so. Everything that I have said is verifiable and supported by official documents available on the Internet.

I welcome and look forward to comments.

Brandon

What is really sad is that

What is really sad is that you are an adult man, ... oh I take that back "Bay street boy," that is home dissing teachers at 6:40 on a Saturday night!

There is no moral to your story just teenage angst!

Thanks for your comment.

Thanks for your comment. I'm actually surprised that I didn't get your type of comment before.

First I want to defend myself. I'm not comparing salaries of Stock Brokers to Teachers, or Lawyers to Teachers. I am only comparing salaries of teachers from one part of the country to another part. It doesn't make sense for a teacher doing the exact same thing in one part of the country getting paid half the salary in the other part of the country (keeping all other things equal, such as living expenses), especially if these salaries are mandated, and not negotiated by individuals, as in the private sector.

Anyway, the other part of your comment bad mouths teachers in general. I realize that there is that sentiment among a lot of people. I might have been one of those people before I became a teacher. I agree to a certain extent that teachers are whiners and sometimes we don't know how good we have it, but please believe me that teaching isn't all that easy. Convincing you about that would be pointless, however. Only becoming a teacher would probably change your mind (as it did in my case).

Thanks for your comment, and I know you're not alone in your thinking.

Looking at a 2008 copy of

Looking at a 2008 copy of the Winnipeg Teacher/Clinician Salary Schedule, I see that a teacher of 8 years in Class 5 (which you would be unless you have a masters) would earn $69,689. This is less than the figure you posted. Where did you find your numbers?

I gave the link in the post,

I gave the link in the post, but here is the more specific link: https://www.mbteach.org/cbs/agreements/2008/winni_08

I assumed I was class 6 though (6 years of education. 2 degrees).

teaching in quebec

I`m a teacher and have been living in Quebec for the past several months. While I certainly must agree that the difference in salaries as per the chart above is astonsihing, I have to bring up a few points. First, I should say that my rent in Toronto was upwards of 1400 dollars per month, my car insurance nearly 3000 per year, medical costs through the roof due to no subsidized drug plan, child care benefits 200 dollars per month less than they are in Quebec, and daycare costs of nearly 1000 per month. In Montreal, we were able to buy a 4 bedroom house for 190.000 dollars, I receive 207 dollars more per month for child care, my daycare costs are 7 dollars per day, and my costs for insurance (INCLUDING 2 cars, the house AND life)are 180 dollars per month compared to 270 in Toronto. So while I COMEPLETLY agree that a teacher`s salary of 45000 with a masters degree and 7 years experience is apalling, I have to defend Quebec at least a little bit! Finally: I definately think they will have to wake up and catch up soon; too many teachers are leaving. So here`s hoping!